New York Mets vs New York Yankees, May 16, 2026

YankeesNYY
3-6
Final
MetsNYM

May 16, 2026, 7:15 PM ET | Citi Field

Last 5 Form

New York Yankees

2-3

Last 5
L 2-3
@ BAL
W 6-2
@ BAL
L 0-7
@ BAL
W 5-2
@ NYM
L 3-6
@ NYM

New York Mets

4-1

Last 5
W 10-2
vs DET
W 3-2
vs DET
W 9-4
vs DET
L 2-5
vs NYY
W 6-3
vs NYY

Starting Pitchers

New York Yankees

Carlos Rodón headshot
Carlos Rodón
Recorded starter

New York Mets

Huascar Brazobán headshot
Huascar Brazobán
Recorded starter

Standings Snapshot

Full standings
Season recordsRecord, division and wild card rank, games back. Standings as of May 16, 11:25 PM ET
TeamW-LPCTDivWCGB
New York Yankees28-18.609#2#12.0
New York Mets19-26.422#5#1011.5
PCT
winning percentage
Div
division rank
WC
wild card rank
GB
games back

Season Comparison

2026
New York YankeesNew York Mets
.720
OPS
.706
223
HR
204
739
Runs
699
3.23
ERA
4.15
1.17
WHIP
1.29
1450
Strikeouts by pitchers
1450

Lower is better for ERA and WHIP; bars show each value against the larger of the two.

Top Players

Across up to five recent games with recorded boxscores.

New York Yankees

Hitters

Ben Rice headshot
Ben Rice

6 H, 2 HR, 3 RBI

Trent Grisham headshot
Trent Grisham

2 H, 1 HR, 4 RBI

Paul Goldschmidt headshot
Paul Goldschmidt

5 H, 1 HR, 2 RBI

Pitchers

Cam Schlittler headshot
Cam Schlittler

6.2 IP, 9 SO, 1.35 ERA

Ryan Weathers headshot
Ryan Weathers

6.1 IP, 9 SO, 2.84 ERA

Ryan Yarbrough headshot
Ryan Yarbrough

3.0 IP, 4 SO, 3.00 ERA

New York Mets

Hitters

Juan Soto headshot
Juan Soto

7 H, 2 HR, 4 RBI

Mark Vientos headshot
Mark Vientos

5 H, 1 HR, 6 RBI

Brett Baty headshot
Brett Baty

7 H, 1 HR, 4 RBI

Pitchers

Austin Warren headshot
Austin Warren

3.2 IP, 5 SO, 0.00 ERA

Huascar Brazobán headshot
Huascar Brazobán

3.2 IP, 4 SO, 0.00 ERA

Luke Weaver headshot
Luke Weaver

3.0 IP, 3 SO, 0.00 ERA

Top Performers

Picked by MLBDB from this game's box score. MLB's own list of top performers can differ.

David Peterson headshot
David Peterson
New York Mets, MLBDB pick
Carlos Rodón headshot
Carlos Rodón
New York Yankees, MLBDB pick
Mark Vientos headshot
Mark Vientos
New York Mets, MLBDB pick

Line Score

New York Mets 6, New York Yankees 3: NYY 9 hits, NYM 8 hits; NYY 1 error, NYM 1 error.

Runs by inningThen runs (R), hits (H) and errors (E) for the game
Team123456789RHE
New York Yankees010010100391
New York Mets00212010x681

Box Score

Batting

3 players led New York Yankees with 2 hits each.

New York Yankees batting
PlayerABRHRBIBBSOHR
Ben RiceDH4100000
Aaron JudgeRF4120110
Cody BellingerLF5000020
Paul Goldschmidt1B4021010
Jazz Chisholm Jr.2B5120020
Amed Rosario3B4010020
Trent GrishamCF4011030
Anthony VolpeSS2000200
Austin WellsC4010030
Totals363923140

Carson Benge led New York Mets with 3 hits.

New York Mets batting
PlayerABRHRBIBBSOHR
Carson BengeRF4230000
Bo BichetteSS3200100
Juan SotoLF2120200
Mark Vientos1B4013010
Marcus Semien2B4000020
A.J. EwingCF4010010
Austin SlaterDH2100110
MJ MelendezPH/DH0000100
Brett Baty3B4011030
Luis TorrensC4000030
Totals316845110

Pitching

Carlos Rodón went 3.2 innings for New York Yankees (6 SO, 2 ER); David Peterson went 4.0 innings for New York Mets (8 SO, 2 ER).

Pitching lines
PitcherIPHRERBBSOHR
New York Yankees
Carlos Rodón3.2332360
Jake Bird0.2111010
Brent Headrick1.2111130
Tim Hill0.1211000
Camilo Doval0.2000000
Paul Blackburn1.0100110
New York Mets
Huascar Brazobán1.1000020
David Peterson4.0622380
Brooks Raley0.2210010
Luke Weaver2.0100020
Devin Williams1.0000010
AB
at-bats
R
runs
H
hits
RBI
runs batted in
BB
walks
SO
strikeouts
HR
home runs
IP
innings pitched
ER
earned runs

Scoring Summary

  • T2

    Single Trent Grisham singles on a ground ball to left fielder Juan Soto. Jazz Chisholm Jr. scores. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • B3

    Groundout Mark Vientos grounds out, third baseman Amed Rosario to first baseman Paul Goldschmidt. NYY 1, NYM 2

  • B4

    Double Brett Baty doubles (7) on a line drive to right fielder Aaron Judge. Austin Slater scores. NYY 1, NYM 3

  • T5

    Single Paul Goldschmidt singles on a ground ball to right fielder Carson Benge. Ben Rice scores. Cody Bellinger to 2nd. NYY 2, NYM 3

  • B5

    Double Mark Vientos doubles (6) on a ground ball to left fielder Cody Bellinger, deflected by third baseman Amed Rosario. Carson Benge scores. Juan Soto scores. NYY 2, NYM 5

  • T7

    Field Error Cody Bellinger reaches on a fielding error by right fielder Carson Benge. Aaron Judge scores. Cody Bellinger to 2nd. NYY 3, NYM 5

  • B7

    Groundout Mark Vientos grounds out, second baseman Jazz Chisholm Jr. to first baseman Paul Goldschmidt. Bo Bichette scores. NYY 3, NYM 6

Play-by-Play

All 77 recorded plate appearances, newest first.

  • T9

    Groundout Jazz Chisholm Jr. grounds out to first baseman Mark Vientos. NYY 3, NYM 6

  • T9

    Flyout Paul Goldschmidt flies out to left fielder Juan Soto. NYY 3, NYM 6

  • T9

    Strikeout Cody Bellinger strikes out swinging. NYY 3, NYM 6

  • B8

    Flyout Luis Torrens flies out to center fielder Trent Grisham. NYY 3, NYM 6

  • B8

    Strikeout Brett Baty strikes out swinging. NYY 3, NYM 6

  • B8

    Walk MJ Melendez walks. NYY 3, NYM 6

  • B8

    Single A.J. Ewing singles on a ground ball to shortstop Anthony Volpe, deflected by third baseman Amed Rosario. NYY 3, NYM 6

  • T8

    Flyout Aaron Judge flies out to center fielder A.J. Ewing. NYY 3, NYM 6

  • T8

    Grounded Into DP Ben Rice grounds into a double play, first baseman Mark Vientos to shortstop Bo Bichette to pitcher Luke Weaver. Austin Wells out at 2nd. Ben Rice out at 1st. NYY 3, NYM 6

  • T8

    Single Austin Wells singles on a ground ball to right fielder Carson Benge. NYY 3, NYM 6

  • B7

    Groundout Marcus Semien grounds out, third baseman Amed Rosario to first baseman Paul Goldschmidt. NYY 3, NYM 6

  • B7

    Groundout Mark Vientos grounds out, second baseman Jazz Chisholm Jr. to first baseman Paul Goldschmidt. Bo Bichette scores. NYY 3, NYM 6

  • B7

    Single Juan Soto singles on a ground ball to right fielder Aaron Judge. Bo Bichette to 3rd. NYY 3, NYM 5

  • B7

    Forceout Bo Bichette grounds into a force out, pitcher Tim Hill to shortstop Anthony Volpe. Carson Benge out at 2nd. Bo Bichette to 1st. NYY 3, NYM 5

  • B7

    Single Carson Benge singles on a ground ball to third baseman Amed Rosario. NYY 3, NYM 5

  • T7

    Forceout Anthony Volpe grounds into a force out, shortstop Bo Bichette to second baseman Marcus Semien. Jazz Chisholm Jr. out at 2nd. NYY 3, NYM 5

  • T7

    Strikeout Trent Grisham strikes out swinging. NYY 3, NYM 5

  • T7

    Strikeout Amed Rosario strikes out on a foul tip. NYY 3, NYM 5

  • T7

    Single Jazz Chisholm Jr. singles on a soft bunt pop to second baseman Marcus Semien. Cody Bellinger to 3rd. Paul Goldschmidt to 2nd. NYY 3, NYM 5

  • T7

    Hit By Pitch Paul Goldschmidt hit by pitch. NYY 3, NYM 5

  • T7

    Field Error Cody Bellinger reaches on a fielding error by right fielder Carson Benge. Aaron Judge scores. Cody Bellinger to 2nd. NYY 3, NYM 5

  • T7

    Double Aaron Judge doubles (8) on a line drive to left fielder Juan Soto. NYY 2, NYM 5

  • B6

    Strikeout Luis Torrens called out on strikes. NYY 2, NYM 5

  • B6

    Strikeout Brett Baty called out on strikes. NYY 2, NYM 5

  • B6

    Flyout Austin Slater flies out to right fielder Aaron Judge. NYY 2, NYM 5

  • T6

    Groundout Ben Rice grounds out, first baseman Mark Vientos to pitcher Brooks Raley. NYY 2, NYM 5

  • T6

    Strikeout Austin Wells strikes out swinging. NYY 2, NYM 5

  • T6

    Walk Anthony Volpe walks. NYY 2, NYM 5

  • T6

    Strikeout Trent Grisham called out on strikes. NYY 2, NYM 5

  • T6

    Double Amed Rosario doubles (3) on a line drive to left fielder Juan Soto. NYY 2, NYM 5

  • B5

    Strikeout A.J. Ewing strikes out swinging. NYY 2, NYM 5

  • B5

    Groundout Marcus Semien grounds out, third baseman Amed Rosario to first baseman Paul Goldschmidt. NYY 2, NYM 5

  • B5

    Double Mark Vientos doubles (6) on a ground ball to left fielder Cody Bellinger, deflected by third baseman Amed Rosario. Carson Benge scores. Juan Soto scores. NYY 2, NYM 5

  • B5

    Walk Juan Soto walks. Carson Benge to 2nd. NYY 2, NYM 3

  • B5

    Pop Out Bo Bichette pops out to second baseman Jazz Chisholm Jr. NYY 2, NYM 3

  • B5

    Single Carson Benge singles on a ground ball to center fielder Trent Grisham. NYY 2, NYM 3

  • T5

    Strikeout Jazz Chisholm Jr. strikes out swinging. NYY 2, NYM 3

  • T5

    Single Paul Goldschmidt singles on a ground ball to right fielder Carson Benge. Ben Rice scores. Cody Bellinger to 2nd. NYY 2, NYM 3

  • T5

    Forceout Cody Bellinger grounds into a force out, fielded by shortstop Bo Bichette. Ben Rice to 3rd. Aaron Judge out at 2nd. Cody Bellinger to 1st. NYY 1, NYM 3

  • T5

    Walk Aaron Judge walks. Ben Rice to 2nd. NYY 1, NYM 3

  • T5

    Hit By Pitch Ben Rice hit by pitch. NYY 1, NYM 3

  • T5

    Strikeout Austin Wells strikes out swinging. NYY 1, NYM 3

  • B4

    Strikeout Luis Torrens called out on strikes. NYY 1, NYM 3

  • B4

    Double Brett Baty doubles (7) on a line drive to right fielder Aaron Judge. Austin Slater scores. NYY 1, NYM 3

  • B4

    Walk Austin Slater walks. NYY 1, NYM 2

  • B4

    Groundout A.J. Ewing grounds out softly, pitcher Carlos Rodón to first baseman Paul Goldschmidt. NYY 1, NYM 2

  • B4

    Strikeout Marcus Semien strikes out swinging. NYY 1, NYM 2

  • T4

    Flyout Anthony Volpe flies out to right fielder Carson Benge. NYY 1, NYM 2

  • T4

    Strikeout Luis Torrens challenged (pitch result), call on the field was overturned: Trent Grisham called out on strikes. NYY 1, NYM 2

  • T4

    Strikeout Amed Rosario strikes out swinging. NYY 1, NYM 2

  • B3

    Groundout Mark Vientos grounds out, third baseman Amed Rosario to first baseman Paul Goldschmidt. NYY 1, NYM 2

  • B3

    Walk Juan Soto walks. Carson Benge to 3rd. Bo Bichette to 2nd. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • B3

    Walk Bo Bichette walks. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • B3

    Double Carson Benge doubles (6) on a sharp line drive to right fielder Aaron Judge. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • B3

    Strikeout Luis Torrens called out on strikes. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • B3

    Strikeout Brett Baty strikes out swinging. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • T3

    Strikeout Jazz Chisholm Jr. strikes out swinging. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • T3

    Single Paul Goldschmidt singles on a line drive to left fielder Juan Soto. Aaron Judge to 3rd. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • T3

    Strikeout Cody Bellinger called out on strikes. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • T3

    Single Aaron Judge singles on a line drive to right fielder Carson Benge. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • T3

    Groundout Ben Rice grounds out, second baseman Marcus Semien to first baseman Mark Vientos. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • B2

    Strikeout Austin Slater called out on strikes. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • B2

    Flyout A.J. Ewing flies out to left fielder Cody Bellinger. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • B2

    Strikeout Marcus Semien strikes out on a foul tip. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • T2

    Strikeout Austin Wells called out on strikes. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • T2

    Walk Anthony Volpe walks. Trent Grisham to 2nd. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • T2

    Single Trent Grisham singles on a ground ball to left fielder Juan Soto. Jazz Chisholm Jr. scores. NYY 1, NYM 0

  • T2

    Groundout Amed Rosario grounds out, pitcher David Peterson to first baseman Mark Vientos. Jazz Chisholm Jr. to 3rd. NYY 0, NYM 0

  • T2

    Double Jazz Chisholm Jr. doubles (9) on a line drive to right fielder Carson Benge. NYY 0, NYM 0

  • T2

    Strikeout Paul Goldschmidt strikes out swinging. NYY 0, NYM 0

  • B1

    Strikeout Mark Vientos strikes out on a foul tip. NYY 0, NYM 0

  • B1

    Single Juan Soto singles on a ground ball to right fielder Aaron Judge. NYY 0, NYM 0

  • B1

    Lineout Bo Bichette lines out to center fielder Trent Grisham. NYY 0, NYM 0

  • B1

    Groundout Carson Benge grounds out, first baseman Paul Goldschmidt to pitcher Carlos Rodón. NYY 0, NYM 0

  • T1

    Groundout Cody Bellinger grounds out to catcher Luis Torrens. NYY 0, NYM 0

  • T1

    Strikeout Aaron Judge strikes out swinging. NYY 0, NYM 0

  • T1

    Pop Out Ben Rice pops out to catcher Luis Torrens in foul territory. NYY 0, NYM 0